Is Your Dog Dominant?

Today many believe they must dominate their dog in order for their dog to be calm, relaxed, obedient and even happy. Some, or most, believe they or another person they know has a dominant dog when talking about the way they are towards other dogs. This post is not written so anyone should feel bad about themselves or the way they think, but only because I want to provide information that I have learned from entering a webinar (seminar on the internet using a web camera) with the Norwegian ethologist Gry Løberg on this very subject, reading different books about this and scrolling through different pages on the internet.

So what is dominance?
When speaking of ethology, dominance is something that occurs over time in a specific relationship between two individuals – dogs in this case. Dominance is something that in most cases, if not all, changes from situation to situation, and also from the value of the resource in the very same situation.  For example: Dog A may have a dominant position over Dog B, Dog B may have a dominant position over Dog C, and Dog C may have a dominant position over Dog A when it comes to food, if everyone is hungry. But if Dog A isn’t hungry, he may give away his food to Dog B, and thereby recognizing Dog B as the dominant one at that moment. Are you with me so far? This is in no way harmful for Dog A’s general status or for the next meal. The same individuals may have a different status in another given situation, like the best sleeping spot.

This is a picture of my whippet Hugin using calming signals to the dachshund Tettey, lowering his head, sniffing the branch, turning his face away and raising his paw. Tettey is tense and was barking moments before, to say he was not comfortable with Hugin playing wildly around him with the Cairn Terrier Pixel.  Some would say that Tettey was yelling at them to be calm because he wouldn’t tolerate behavior like that, and that he was the dominant leader as he was the one always yelling, but the facts is that he was insecure and sometimes scared of other dogs.

Since dominance is something that develops over time in a relationship, it is wrong to say that «my dog is dominant», as I hear many people say when they are talking about their dog meeting a new dog. They often refer to their dog showing aggressive behavior towards the new dog. But that would be a conflict of some sort, not dominance. E.g. one, or both dogs may be insecure, stressed, aroused, experiencing pain or discomfort and so on. In many cases it may be a conflict of resources.

Dominance and aggression
It is a common mistake to believe that dominance and aggression always comes together. Sure you have aggressive dominant individuals, but this is rare. As quoted (and translated to English by me) from the book «Canine Behavior: A photo Illustrated Handbook» by Barbara Handelman:

«No normal dog will attack out of dominance»

Therefore, besides the ethical point of view, it is safe to say that physically dominating your dog and punishing him «in the name of dominance» is simply wrong, don’t you think?

To sum things up:
Dominance is something developed over time in a relationship between two individuals, and it is not something a dog simply is. This is a small basic post about a much larger subject. It will take me a while to write about types of aggression (often mistaken for dominance) and what to possibly do about this, but if you want me to, I will! Just let me know in the comment section, and I will do so!

Hundetrener og hundeentusiast!

Stikkord: , , , , , ,
Publisert i Atferd, ClickerCanine
8 kommentarer på “Is Your Dog Dominant?
  1. An interesting post Eva, with interesting insights into dog behaviour – more please 🙂

  2. Marcela sier:

    This is one of the best post I’ve ever read:) I liked the way you distinguished dominance and aggressiveness for they are not the same thing. Also, you addressed and pointed out the dogs’ body language which many times go unnoticed by pet parents. If we were more aware and learned about the way dogs interact with one another and with us, we could avoid a lot of «accidents.»

    • ebuhaug sier:

      Thank you for the nice comment!

      I agree. As dog owners it is our obligation to at least get the basic knowledge of the dog’s body language. This is just a part of the responsibility that comes along when we get a dog.

      • Marcela sier:

        If more people thought like you, we’d have a lot less «accidents» involving dogs biting other dogs and people as well.

  3. Very nicely written, thanks for the insight! Please do write more on these 🙂

  4. Bra skrevet, også så mye du kan – er imponert 🙂 Flinking!

Legg igjen en kommentar

Fyll inn i feltene under, eller klikk på et ikon for å logge inn:

Du kommenterer med bruk av din konto. Logg ut /  Endre )


Du kommenterer med bruk av din Google konto. Logg ut /  Endre )


Du kommenterer med bruk av din Twitter konto. Logg ut /  Endre )


Du kommenterer med bruk av din Facebook konto. Logg ut /  Endre )

Kobler til %s

Relationships are based on trust, love, honesty and patience
Playtime is funtime! #playtime #funtime #slowmo #superslomo #dogplay #samsung #bordercollie #withgalaxy @samsungnorge
Had a lovely training session with this guy today. For a long while now I have been ill, and my training motivation hit rock bottom, leading to him not being trained to cope with every day life. Extra has not suffered from this, we have not trained these things because they have not been a part of our life. The mayor thing to teach this guy is to stop herding cars, and today's training started at the end of a big field next to the motor high way. We worked our way towards the driving cars, reinforcing contact, calm behaviour and ignoring the cars. The reinforcement was delicious wiener bites and the occasional tug toy when the situation called for it. I am still amazed about the suverinity of this dog! Even though he for 3 years has been herding cars whenever we have gotten close to them, this was an easy training. We got so close to the highway I had to stop because I would not go any closer to the moving cars, not because it was too much for him to handle! It was almost like herding cars never had been any issue at all ever in his life. One should never underestimate the power of reinforcing the behaviour we want of our dogs. I dared having him off leash as shown in the picture here from today, though I am not a fool: I went back to the safer side of the field just in case and I will never have any dog of any sort strolling close to the road off leash. This training session made me remember the good feelings about training dogs, why I used to love it so much and why I wanted border collies in the first place. It was just what I needed to get back in the saddle after such a long absence from what I have been doing for so many years! Today was a good day. Thank you Extra, for being such an awesome dog! 💪 #dogtraining #dogtrainer #positivereinforcement #clickertraining #bordercollie #awesomedog #happydog #dogowner #dogbehaviour
Tag and Luna, the adult and senior! #tricolorbordercollie #redbordercollie #bordercollies #bordercollie #bordercolliesrock #dogsofnorway #dogoftheday #dogsofinstagram #dogsofnorway
Luna has turned senior this year, 7 years old! Time really does fly! #bordercollie #fall #autumn #autumndog #dogphotography #sheepdog #instadog #dogsofnorway #redbordercollie
I just love the classic looking border collies! #bordercollie #fall #autumn #autumndog #dogphotography #sheepdog #instadog #dogsofnorway #classicbordercollie #bordercolliesrock
Extra waving his fluffy tail! #bordercollie #fall #autumn #autumndog #dogphotography #sheepdog #instadog #dogsofnorway #bordercolliesrock
Extra posing in the fields! #bordercollie #fall #autumn #autumndog #dogphotography #sheepdog #instadog #dogsofnorway #sheepdog #classicbordercollie #bordercolliesrock
Luna and Tag #bordercollie #redbordercollie #shorthairedbordercollie #autumn #autumndog #dogphotography #dogsofinstagram #instadog
Luna is enjoying lazy days on the couch, just waiting for the next chance to smooch the baby 👶❤ #bordercollie #lazydog #couchpotato #dogsofnorway #dogphotography #dogstagram #redbordercollie
%d bloggere like this: